Five reasons Christian communes don’t work
September 25, 2019
Posted by on
1. They isolate members from other people
Relationships with family and friends outside the community that do not further the goals of the community become suspect.
2. They disconnect members from the reality of the world around them
People who don’t have to choose and pay for their own food, clothing and shelter can hardly relate to the people around them who do.
3. Giving is mandatory, not voluntary
When someone joins a commune, he voluntarily gives all he has to the community. After that he is assigned tasks to do for the well-being of the community.
4. Conversion becomes merely assent to the values of the community
When one’s home and livelihood are tied to being a member, young people who grow up in the community face enormous pressure to make an outward commitment to the faith of the community. Those who are already members also face pressure to admit young people on such a basis, for the continuation of the community.
5. Allegiance to the community outranks a relationship with God
Since the community is believed to be the ultimate expression of the will of God, a personal relationship with God and being led of the Holy Spirit are taught to be synonymous with living in accordance with the values of the community.
Sharing of material blessings received from God, mutual aid, bearing one another’s burdens, helping the poor and the weak are all values clearly taught in the New Testament. But they are taught as voluntary actions proceeding from a heart that is transformed by the Spirit of God.
2 Corinthians 9:7 – Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver.